Skip to main content

What is "responsive design"?

This is a question that I get asked quite frequently. Most of what I would want to say on the topic is in this paper I wrote with Mick Couper a couple of years ago.

I have been thinking that a little historical context might help in answering such a question. I'm not sure the paper we wrote does that. I imagine that surveys of old were designed ahead of time, carried out, and then evaluated after they were complete. Probably too simple, but it makes sense. In field surveys, it was hard to even know what was happening until it was all over.

As response rates declined, it became more difficult to manage surveys. The uncertainty grew. Surveys ended up making ad hoc changes more and more frequently. "Oh no, we aren't hitting our targets. Increase the incentive!" That seems like a bad process. There isn't any planning, so bad decisions and inefficiency are more likely. And it's hard to replicate a survey that includes a "panic" phase.

Not to put words in their mouths, but Groves and Heeringa wanted to address this situation. They give a conceptual outline for how to do so. Their approach emphasizes pre-planning (risk management) and experimentation aimed at making optimal or nearly-optimal choices with the information at hand.

To me, that's a dividing line between "ad hoc"changes and responsive design. That allows to create reproducible procedures. It also allows us to design surveys in a way that could be described as optimal, given information deficits (i.e. uncertainty).

We could probably look backwards to the "pre-Responsive Design" era and find examples of responsive design. But Groves and Heeringa gave us a systematic way to think about the problem and to create replicable research.
Labels:

Comments

  1. UnknownNovember 18, 2014 at 1:27 AM

    For a Business website is very very must.In website the designing part is very very important.
    Web Design Company in Coimbatore | Best IT Company in Coimbatore

    ReplyDelete
  2. Logic Web TechnologiesJuly 25, 2015 at 7:22 AM

    Best SEO Services Affordable Packages and Prices - SEO Experts in coimbatore, chennai Tamil Nadu, India Search engine Optimization Company in india

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Tailoring vs. Targeting

One of the chapters in a recent book on surveying hard-to-reach populations looks at "targeting and tailoring" survey designs. The chapter references this paper on the use of the terms among those who design health communication. I thought the article was an interesting one. They start by saying that "one way to classify message strategies like tailoring is by the level of specificity with which characteristics of the target audience are reflected in the the communication." That made sense. There is likely a continuum of specificity ranging from complete non-differentiation across units to nearly individualized. But then the authors break that continuum and try to define a "fundamental" difference between tailoring and targeting. They say targeting is for some subgroup while tailoring is to the characteristics of the individual. That sounds good, but at least for surveys, I'm not sure the distinction holds. In survey design, what would constitute
36 comments
Read more

What is Data Quality, and How to Enhance it in Research

  We often talk about “data quality” or “data integrity” when we are discussing the collection or analysis of one type of data or another. Yet, the definition of these terms might be unclear, or they may vary across different contexts. In any event, the terms are somewhat abstract -- which can make it difficult, in practice, to improve. That is, we need to know what we are describing with those terms, before we can improve them. Over the last two years, we have been developing a course on   Total Data Quality , soon to be available on Coursera. We start from an error classification scheme adopted by survey methodology many years ago. Known as the “Total Survey Error” perspective, it focuses on the classification of errors into measurement and representation dimensions. One goal of our course is to expand this classification scheme from survey data to other types of data. The figure shows the classification scheme as we have modified it to include both survey data and organic forms of d
Post a Comment
Read more

An Experimental Adaptive Contact Strategy

I'm running an experiment on contact methods in a telephone survey. I'm going to present the results of the experiment at the FCSM conference in November. Here's the basic idea. Multi-level models are fit daily with the household being a grouping factor. The models provide household-specific estimates of the probability of contact for each of four call windows. The predictor variables in this model are the geographic context variables available for an RDD sample. Let $\mathbf{X_{ij}}$ denote a $k_j \times 1$ vector of demographic variables for the $i^{th}$ person and $j^{th}$ call. The data records are calls. There may be zero, one, or multiple calls to household in each window. The outcome variable is an indicator for whether contact was achieved on the call. This contact indicator is denoted $R_{ijl}$ for the $i^{th}$ person on the $j^{th}$ call to the $l^{th}$ window. Then for each of the four call windows denoted $l$, a separate model is fit where each household is assu
4 comments
Read more